| Steve Young, SF (Miller Time) | 375 |
| Brett Favre, GB (Tree Huggin' Hippies) | 289 |
| Randall Cunningham, MIN (Midnight Marauders) | 246 |
| Chris Chandler, ATL (Attitude Adjustment) | 233 |
| Steve McNair, TEN (Toin Coss) | 225 |
| Vinny Testaverde, NYJ (Toin Coss) | 214 |
| Drew Bledsoe, NE (Psychos) | 207 |
| Mark Brunell, JAC (Miller Time) | 197 |
| Dan Marino, MIA (The JV Experience) | 186 |
| John Elway, DEN (The JV Experience) | 182 |
| Peyton Manning, IND (Midnight Marauders) | 152 |
| Kordell Stewart, PIT (Rage) | 151 |
| Steve Beuerlein, CAR (T and A) | 138 |
| Charlie Batch, DET (Rage) | 125 |
| Tony Banks, STL (T and A) | 120 |
| Jake Plummer, ARI (T and A) | 117 |
| Doug Flutie, BUF (Tree Huggin' Hippies) | 115 |
| Rich Gannon, KC (Attitude Adjustment) | 115 |
| Warren Moon, SEA (Thundering Herd) | 109 |
| Trent Dilfer, TB (Midnight Marauders) | 96 |
| Erik Kramer, CHI (Midnight Marauders) | 95 |
| Troy Aikman, DAL (Thundering Herd) | 83 |
| Neil O'Donnell, CIN (Attitude Adjustment) | 77 |
| Donald Hollas, OAK (Psychos) | 67 |
| Kerry Collins, NO (Psychos) | 64 |
| Danny Kanell, NYG (Rage) | 63 |
| Rob Johnson, BUF (The JV Experience) | 56 |
| Trent Green, WAS (Tree Huggin' Hippies) | 53 |
| Jeff George, OAK (Psychos) | 50 |
| Brad Johnson, MIN (Midnight Marauders) | 33 |
| Jason Garret, DAL (Toin Coss) | 30 |
| Elvis Grbac, KC (Attitude Adjustment) | 30 |
| Eric Zeier, BAL (The JV Experience) | 30 |
| Ryan Leaf, SD (Thundering Herd) | 21 |
| Scott Mitchell, DET (Tree Huggin' Hippies) | 21 |
| Danny Wuerffel, NO () | 18 |
| Jim Harbaugh, BAL (The JV Experience) | 12 |
| Glenn Foley, NYJ (T and A) | 10 |
| Rodney Peete, PHI (Psychos) | 7 |
| Bobby Hoying, PHI (Psychos) | 5 |
| Jamie Martin, JAC (Miller Time) | 3 |