| Morten Anderson, ATL (Psychos) | 112 |
| Jason Elam, DEN (Tree Huggin' Hippies) | 112 |
| Richie Cunningham, DAL (Thundering Herd) | 110 |
| Jason Hanson, DET (T and A) | 110 |
| Mike Hollis, JAC (Rage) | 106 |
| John Hall, NYJ (Midnight Marauders) | 95 |
| Gary Anderson, MIN (The JV Experience) | 89 |
| Olindo Mare, MIA (Toin Coss) | 89 |
| Al Del Greco, TEN (Miller Time) | 80 |
| Norm Johnson, PIT (Attitude Adjustment) | 69 |
| Pete Stoyanovich, KC (The JV Experience) | 61 |
| Todd Peterson, SEA (Attitude Adjustment) | 26 |
| Wade Richie, SF (Tree Huggin' Hippies) | 26 |
| Adam Vinatieri, NE (Miller Time) | 18 |
| John Kasay, CAR (Toin Coss) | 17 |
| Greg Davis, OAK (Rage) | 11 |
| Jeff Wilkins, STL (Midnight Marauders) | 10 |
| Matt Stover, BAL (T and A) | 6 |