| QB Brett Favre, GB | 28 |
| RB Robert Edwards, NE | 27 |
| QB Doug Flutie, BUF | 15 |
| RB Fred Taylor, JAC | 12 |
| WR Terance Mathis, ATL | 10 |
| PK Jason Elam, DEN | 7 |
| TE Frank Wycheck, TEN | 7 |
| WR Keyshawn Johnson, NYJ | 6 |
| WR Rod Smith, DEN | 4 |
| RB Curtis Martin, NYJ | 3 |
| Oakland Defense | 12 |
| San Francisco Defense | 5 |