| WR Antonio Freeman, GB | 36 |
| QB Dan Marino, MIA | 31 |
| WR Yancey Thigpen, TEN | 15 |
| PK Gary Anderson, MIN | 14 |
| RB Garrison Hearst, SF | 11 |
| WR Eric Moulds, BUF | 10 |
| QB John Elway, DEN | 6 |
| RB John Avery, MIA | 3 |
| RB Marshall Faulk, IND | 2 |
| Tampa Bay Defense | 16 |
| Kansas City Defense | 2 |