| RB Emmitt Smith, DAL | 211 |
| RB Robert Smith, MIN | 172 |
| WR Cris Carter, MIN | 152 |
| QB Kordell Stewart, PIT | 151 |
| QB Charlie Batch, DET | 125 |
| RB Mike Alstott, TB | 113 |
| TE Shannon Sharpe, DEN | 112 |
| PK Mike Hollis, JAC | 106 |
| WR J.J. Stokes, SF | 86 |
| WR Chris Calloway, NYG | 72 |
| QB Danny Kanell, NYG | 63 |
| RB Charles Way, NYG | 53 |
| RB Thurman Thomas, BUF | 14 |
| PK Greg Davis, OAK | 11 |
| RB Rodney Thomas, TEN | 9 |
| WR Jeff Graham, PHI | 2 |
| Seattle Defense | 241 |
| Green Bay Defense | 183 |
| San Diego Defense | 41 |