| QB Randall Cunningham, MIN | 246 |
| QB Peyton Manning, IND | 152 |
| RB Napoleon Kaufman, OAK | 110 |
| WR Keenan McCardell, JAC | 110 |
| WR Tony Martin, ATL | 97 |
| QB Trent Dilfer, TB | 96 |
| PK John Hall, NYJ | 95 |
| QB Erik Kramer, CHI | 95 |
| WR Muhsin Muhammed, CAR | 57 |
| TE Tony Gonzalez, KC | 53 |
| WR Rob Moore, ARI | 51 |
| RB Kimble Anders, KC | 43 |
| RB Larry Centers, ARI | 36 |
| QB Brad Johnson, MIN | 33 |
| PK Jeff Wilkins, STL | 10 |
| RB Tavian Banks, JAC | 9 |
| WR Reidel Anthony, TB | 6 |
| RB Harvey Williams, OAK | 3 |
| WR Irving Fryar, PHI | 1 |
| New England Defense | 149 |
| Tennessee Defense | 84 |
| Washington Defense | -7 |