| RB Jerome Bettis, PIT | 16 |
| QB Chris Chandler, ATL | 15 |
| WR Curtis Conway, CHI | 14 |
| PK Norm Johnson, PIT | 6 |
| TE Freddie Jones, SD | 5 |
| WR Carl Pickens, CIN | 3 |
| RB Terrell Davis, DEN | 2 |
| WR Andre Reed, BUF | 2 |
| RB Priest Holmes, BAL | 1 |
| QB Rich Gannon, KC | -1 |
| Saint Louis Defense | 12 |
| Buffalo Defense | 6 |