Howdy and welcome to another year of fantasy football! As always, I (Rich) perform an analysis on the fantasy draft and then I mock people and their rosters. A word to the wise: The 2004 Draft Analysis is not for the weak of heart. If you’re too sensitive to hear that your team sucks, then stop reading this article now. At any rate, I’m sure everyone just wants to jump right into this. But first, a quick word about how the analysis works (as the algorithm changes slightly from year to year):
The first step in the
Fusinski
Draft Analysis is to write down the starters at each position, and then
rate
the backups at those positions.
Essentially, a Backups rating of Y means that there are
legitimate
backups here, and a rating of N means there is not.
The Plus and Minus indicates the level of legitimacy
(or lack thereof). For the most part,
the ranking that follows is based on the quality of the starters,
however in
the case of Quarterbacks, the Backup
players are more
heavily weighted into the position ranking because of the frequency of
QB
injury.
After all teams have been ranked at individual positions, the average is taken across the rankings. There are, however, weights to certain positions. For instance, the running back and wide receiver positions are averaged in twice, because there are two starters at these positions. Some people may disagree with me that this is a good way of doing things, but it makes sense to me so SHUT THE HELL UP. Anyway, on to the rankings.
|
|
Starting RBs |
Backups |
Rank |
|
MHTM |
Alexander, Barlow |
Y |
1 |
|
Reservoir |
McAllister, Dillon |
N |
2 |
|
Hostile |
Portis, Faulk |
N |
3 |
|
|
Tomlinson, Westbrook |
Y+ |
4 |
|
Kooter |
Holmes,
Staley |
Y - |
5 |
|
IHOP |
Johnson, Brown |
Y+ |
6 |
|
'tude |
Taylor, Martin |
Y |
7 |
|
DarkSide |
James, Davis |
Y |
8 |
|
JVE |
Bennett, Davis |
Y |
9 |
|
Capitol |
Lewis, Jones |
Y |
10 |
|
T&A |
Green, Suggs |
N |
11 |
|
SSFFPA |
Griffin, Wheatley |
Y - |
12 |
This year's RB spread
was interesting, in the sense that nobody came out of the draft with a
"killer" backfield. MHTM, however, came the closest with
the combination of Shaun Alexander (who is primed for another great
year) and Kevan Barlow who is no longer living in Garrison Hearst's
shadow. These backs combined are capable of surpassing 2800 yards
on the ground and 30 TDs. Playing second fiddle to MHTM is
the Reservior Dogs with the combination of Deuce McAllister and Corey
Dillon. On paper this backfield looks great, and if they reach
their potential the Dogs will be tough. With no servicable
backups, however, hope you play the Dogs on their bye week--and the
same goes for Hostile Takeover, who rounds out our top three. Joe
Sr. has put together a pretty tough 1-2 punch between Portis and
Faulk. Portis should see the same production he's used to under
Joe Gibbs who loves to run, and Faulk, although plagued by a weak
offensive line, should still manage some decent rushing days and is, as
always, a receiving threat as well. Should Faulk go down, Mr. M
was smart enough to draft Stephen Jackson to back him up.
Ranked number four is Chico's Bail Bonds, sporting the always fearsome
LaDainian Tomlinson and the always injured Brian Westbrook.
Westbrook certainly has the potential to be a great #2 fantasy back,
but will he survive an increased role in Philly with his small
stature? We'll see. For now, injury concerns will keep
Chico out of the top three in the RB rankings. Without Westbrook,
Jason is forced to go with Charlie Garner, who hasn't been the same
since leaving Oakland. At least he has a starting backup, though,
which is more than we can say for fifth-RB-ranked Kooter, who drafted
Priest Holmes with the coveted #1 selection in the draft but failed to
secure a decent reservist. Complementing Priest is new Pittsburgh
Steeler Duce Staley, who frankly the jury is still out on. My gut
tells me that the Bus is never actually going to lose much playing time
until he's 60 years old. The guy was supposed to be done in Pitt
for about a decade now but keeps getting carries. Even so, Holmes
is still worth two RBs on a bad day, so who needs backups? Well,
IHOP does. At least, that was their draft strategy this
year. Snag Travis Henry in the middle rounds while everyone is
still scared of him. Between Rudi, Henry, and Chris Brown, who Titans coach Jeff Fisher
said he was going to "run until he dies," IHOP GM Rich doesn't know who is going to emerge
as the starting two just yet, but is confident that all three are a lot
more dangerous than they get credit for. This backfield will
surprise.
The bottom half of the RB rankings starts with Attitude Adjustment, who
frankly we aren't used to seeing here. Usually GM Vince has three
good RBs on his roster, but this year just managed to gather his boy
Fred Taylor or recent Iron Man fame, an aging Curtis Martin who has
delusions of 1500 yard grandeur, and a backup turned starter thanks to
substance abuse in Travis Minor, who may not be starting come week 1 if
a trade goes down. Vince can't be happy with this trio, even
though they will be servicable--at least enough to earn him the 7 spot
in the RB rankings. Speaking of delusions of grandeur, that had
to be what the Dark Side was thinking when they drafted Stephen Davis
as their #2 back. Davis may disappoint this season with the
return of DeShaun Foster to the lineup. RB by committee is a
rough ship to sail for a fantasy owner. And Emmitt Smith,
although a starting RB on paper, is really too far past his prime to
contribute. However, we still figure Davis to touch the ball 20
times a game, which should be good enough to produce average #2 back
numbers--AND we figure Edge will be a stud this year. As far as
studs go, don't look the direction of the JV Experience, who is
sporting the all-nagging-injury backfield in Bennett and Davis.
Bennett is explosive when he is healthy, but when was the last time
that happened? Davis has been experiencing a string of minor
nagging injuries as well--not enough to keep him out, mind you--but
enough to have the coaching staff questioning his durability.
Plus, with Hollings nipping at his heels, JV had better hope Davis
doesn't miss a game or two or he may see decreased production out of
his starter. To his credit, however, potential is really the
theme of this backfield. If healthy, they could be
dangerous. Kevin Jones has potential to be a starter himself if
Mariucci lets the lightning out of the bottle, but I don't see that
happening--which really decreases the values of both Jones and Pinner,
in all liklihood. McGahee would be a great backup if Henry went
down, but likely will be less of a factor than the media hype is
playing him out to be and won't have any real value until next year.
Our bottom three in the rankings begins with Joe's Capitol
Punishment. Lewis is a great back, but I question how much he'll
be able to focus in the face of his federal drug charges, even though I
would like to believe he is innocent. For validation of this
theory, look no further than Kobe Bryant who suffered his worst season
yet. Additionally, Lewis may miss games starting in
November. This would leave Joe with a horriffic backfield with
Thomas Jones as the starter and Eddie George as his #2. Thomas
Jones is garbage, and the hype surrounding this guy borders on the
ridiculous. Two good games and the media is willing to declare
this guy a changed man? I don't buy it, and I doubt I'm alone
here. As far as Eddie George is concerned, he hasn't had any gas
in the tank for the past three years. Eddie is going to lose
carries per game as the season draws closer to December, decreasing his
already strapped value with time. If it makes Joe feel better,
however, his backfield isn't nearly as questionable as Angelo's and
Slater's, who sit at 11th and 12th in the rankings, respectively.
The funny thing about Angelo's backfield is that is has potential to be
devastating--but only if Suggs wins the RB job in Cleveland
outright--and with as much time and money as they have invested in
William Green that is a question to ponder. Likely, there will be
a committee situation here as well, which really hurts Angleo and moves
him down to #11. Ahman Green is great, but without any servicable
backup on this team Angleo could be in a world of hurt. Slater,
who sits at 12, however, is undoubtedly in a world of hurt. Once
you get past Quentin Griffin in this lineup, where do you look?
Tyrone Wheatley? Been there before--that is a failed
experiment. How long will it be until Fargas steals the show, or
more likely the committee rears its ugly head? SSFFPA is going to
have to find an answer somewhere else, either through free agency or
trade if they are going to compete on the RB plane.
|
|
Starting QB |
Backups |
Rank |
|
Kooter |
Manning |
Y++ |
1 |
|
IHOP |
Culpepper |
Y+ |
2 |
|
Reservior |
McNabb |
Y |
3 |
|
|
Vick |
Y |
4 |
|
'tude |
Hasselbeck |
Y |
5 |
|
T&A |
Favre |
Y |
6 |
|
Chico |
Green |
Y |
7 |
|
Hostile |
Bulger |
Y |
8 |
|
MHTM |
Pennington |
Y |
9 |
|
JVE |
Brooks |
Y |
10 |
|
DarkSide |
Brady |
N |
11 |
|
Capitol |
Palmer |
Y - |
12 |
|
|
Starting WRs |
Backups |
Rank |
|
Chico |
Holt, Ward |
Y+ |
1 |
|
T&A |
Owens, Jackson |
Y |
2 |
|
SSFFPA |
Harrison, Smith |
Y |
3 |
|
|
Moss, A. Johnson |
Y |
4 |
|
MHTM |
Mason,
S. Smith |
Y |
5 |
|
Kooter |
Moss, Walker |
Y |
6 |
|
Capitol |
Horn, Rogers |
Y - |
7 |
|
IHOP |
Moulds, Bruce |
Y - |
8 |
|
'tude |
Price, Robinson |
Y - |
9 |
|
DarkSide |
Coles, Burress |
Y - |
10 |
|
Reservior |
Chambers, K. Johnson |
Y |
11 |
|
Hostile |
C. Johnson, Fitzgerald |
Y - |
12 |
Things really get interesting on the Wide Receiver front. More
interesting than I've seen in years, I think. Because of this,
the WR rankings are going to have my most in-depth analysis--what a
change of pace! For starters, there is a clear cut favorite
here. Chico's Bail Bonds is without question the class of the
draft in this category. Torry Holt--whose numbers have potential
to even pass the mighty Randy Moss--is my favorite receiver as of late
and a consistent fantasy numbers powerhouse. If there was any
question as to whether Torry was going to keep the pace he set last
year, look no further than the last preseason game where he racked up
150 yards in the first half. He and Mark Bulger aren't only on
the same page, they are on the same brainwave. Combine him with
Hines Ward--another top-5 receiver, and you have yourself a dominant
tandem. But kids, the fun doesn't stop there. If you're
playing GM Jason Miller in week 7 or 8, you will still have to contend
with the likes of Rod Smith or Donald Driver. This guy has 5...
count 'em... 5 number ones on his team, and that's not even counting
holdout Keenan McCardell who is another very capable wideout (almost as
capable as David Boston). There is some serious trade bait on
this team and we fully expect GM Jason to move some talent around
before the trade deadline expires.
So that gets Jason out of the way, but what about everyone else?
Well, there are some other dangerous receiver corps out there this
year, too. This was a very deep WR draft, and it shows by the
following tandems:
Ranked #2 -- Terrell Owens / Darrell Jackson: These are a couple of WRs
to be seriously feared--GM Angelo has some serious explosiveness here,
albeit two WRs with cases of the dropsies. Owens is coming off
the worst season in his modern career and looks to revive huge numbers
in Philadelphia behind the arm of underrated passer Donovan
McNabb. McNabb is locked into this guy--if T.O. can keep his head
on straight, he's going to be dangerous as all hell. Darrell
Jackson is sort of the same way--when he can limit his mistakes, he is
capable of huge games week in and week out. The bottom line here
is that these are two top-10 receivers who are going to get T&A a
few wins all by themselves.
Ranked #3 -- Marvin Harrison / Jimmy Smith: No slowing down for Marvin,
and Jimmy is going to come back in a big way. The Peyton Manning
to Marvin Harrison connection is virtually unstoppable, and look for
that to continue in a big way with 2004 being a contract year for the
wideout. Jimmy Smith is way on the wrong side of 30, but QB
Leftwich should make big strides this season and revive the aging
star's statistics. Don't expect 1600 yards like in '99, but
remember this guy still went for 800 and 4 scores in just 12 games this
year with his best yards per catch in five seasons, so 1100-1200 yards
and 8 TDs doesn't seem unreasonable with an improved young QB under
center.
Ranked #4 -- Randy Moss / Andre Johnson: This ranking was my most
difficult to pin-point, and could have easily been as high as number
two. I gave in, however, to the fact that Andre Johnson is still
an unproven commodity, even though I personally like him a lot. A
breakout year is expected for young wideout Johnson, and this guy is primed for stardom a year ahead of
normal WR schedule. In his second year, Johnson is projected to
be a top-15 receiver, and improving QB David Carr's favorite
target. He is explosive with that extra gear, and has tremendous
size and great hands. As for
Moss, what really needs to be said about this guy? Randy
already has 77 touchdowns in his brilliant six-year career, and just
keeps getting better. Last season was his best, as he went off
for
1600+ yards and 17 scores. With QB Daunte Culpepper playing like
he
did last season, don't expect any less from the star. GM JV should really expect big things from his WR
tandem this season.
The next tier of WR pairs isn't quite as fearsome, but will still get
the job done well enough such that they won't be liabilities.
Ranked #5: -- Derrick Mason / Steve Smith: At the head of Tier 2 is
MHTM with a pair of great, reliable WRs. These are both top-notch
wideouts, but aren't really capable of tremendous feats. What can
be expected out of these guys is consistency and the occasional better
than normal week. These are both 1000-1200 yard, 8 TD guys who
can be counted on week in and week out to produce good enough numbers
to keep GM Geoff's team in the running for a win every Sunday.
Ranked #6 -- Santana Moss / Javon Walker: Two guys who really started
to shine last year, and who expect to continue to improve in
2004. Santana Moss has really shown a connection with QB Chad
Pennington, but probably isn't as good as he has looked in the
past. Moss came on as sort of a surprise last season with some
tremendous multi-touchdown games seemingly out of nowhere, but this
year defenses will be ready for him. Defensive coordinators will
want to make Justin McCarens beat them, and in such a tough defensive
division, being that he is too small to be a physical receiver, it is
doubtful that Moss's totals will get any better because of this.
That being said, 1100 yards and 10 scores would be very much welcomed
by GM Boris. As for Javon Walker, this is a guy with a lot of
upside who is battling to be the Pack's top receiver, and is showing
tremendous improvement. It seems like Favre is beginning to
really trust this guy, which means that Walker is going to be getting a
lot of Brett Favre slings towards the endzone--probably more than
complimentary receivers Driver and Ferguson. That being said,
Driver and Ferguson are still hanging around out there seeing a lot of
balls, and as long as they're around Walker will never be great.
He is, however, an excellent #2 fantasy receiver and will not
disappoint as such.
Ranked #7 -- Joe Horn /
Charles Rogers: Joe Horn has always been a solid #1 receiver for some
time now even though he was held to under 1000 yards for the first time
since 1999. The guy was previously good for about 1300 yards for
the three seasons before, so that knee injury he sustained in week 1
makes you wonder how much that's going to impact his effectiveness this
year. He just wasn't the same receiver we had been accustomed to
seeing make quick cuts with blazing speed. Being that he's now
32, I wonder if that is going to be more of the trend than the
anomaly. So that being said, this tandem of receivers really
begins the "Something to Prove" category, especially with second-year
wideout Charles Rogers as the #2 here. Personally, I'm a believer
that Rogers is something special and is going to be a stud... I'm just
not sure it's going to be this year with Harrington still being a
question mark and the offense being so generally young.
Therefore, Team Capitol Punishment is really teetering on the fence
here with one side being toughness and the other being pushover.
I'm giving him the benefit of the doubt here and leaning towards
toughness, with both of these guys producing like #10 to #20 receivers
and generating a pretty decent amount of fantasy points.
This next group of WRs is really the "Something to Prove" category, and
should have their GMs slightly worried about their week to week
production.
Ranked #8 -- Eric Moulds / Isaac Bruce: Talk about a reach--but
potential resulting in serious middle-round value. Eric Moulds
had a great season with Peerless Price on the other side of the field,
but last year suffered greatly from a combination of that loss and Drew
Bledsoe imploding. Well, now with a new offensive coordinator in
Mike Mularkey, I believe Bledsoe is really going to turn it around this
year and Moulds is going to return to 1000 yard, 7-8 TD form with Bruce
throwing in another 1000 and 6-7 scores. Granted this WR tandem
could produce absolute squat, but we had these guys ranked 15 and 20,
respectively, and expect them to produce as such.
Ranked #9 -- Peerless Price / Koren Robinson: Another group of WRs here
that haven't reached their potential in their situations, but both with
the capacity to produce in the range of 15th ranked receivers.
Peerless Price, since leaving Buffalo and benefiting from the presence
of Eric Moulds, has shown his true colors in his inability to really be
a #1 receiver. He's just really not good enough. However,
with the presence of Michael Vick and his threat to run, Price should
see less double coverage and could benefit from some big plays via
broken play/Vick throwing on the run. I expect Price to improve
on his 800 yard, 3 TD season to the tune of something like 1000 yards
and 5 scores. As for Robinson, he was supposed to be the next big
thing but Darrell Jackson seems to have stolen his thunder in
Seattle. Robinson is still young and improving, however, and
should not be discounted yet. Last year the man's stat line was
900 yards and 4 TDs, and should continue to improve along the same line
as Price's projected statistics. GM Vince's group of WR's could
have been ranked #8 ahead of IHOP, but I chose to go with the proven
commodities over the rising potentials.
Ranked #10 -- Laveranues Coles / Plaxico Burress: Coles really started
off strong last season with 400 yards in three games, seriously
inflating his stat line. He only threw up one 100 yard game after
that, and failed to really impress. With the QB situation being
erratic in Washington this year and both QBs failing to impress in the
preseason, we expect Coles' stats to regress from his 2003 campaign to
something in the neighborhood of 1000 yards and 5-6 scores. As
for Burress, this guy really took a step back last year and lost focus,
and never regained it. Burress spent the offseason skipping
mini-camps and voluntary sessions, and what possibly hurts his stock
more is if Pittsburgh gets off to a similar start as they did last year
and QB Maddox is pulled out of the starting lineup in favor of
developing Ben Roethlisberger. I wouldn't expect Burress to post
any better numbers than he did last year, with 860 yards and 4 TDs--and
things could get worse.
Ranked #11 -- Chris Chambers, Keyshawn Johnson, Amani Toomer:
Since I don't really know which two of these guys will start, I'll
discuss them all. Chris Chambers improves every year, but the
offense in Miami seems to get worse every year, too. The loss of
RB Ricky Williams really hurts Chambers' stock, as the run is no longer
a threat in Miami. I would expect Chambers' numbers to be worse
than they were last year without a doubt because of this. Expect
Keyshaun Johnson to has somewhat of a revival in Dallas until
Testaverde runs out of gas or gets hurt. Johnson will have great
fantasy value for about 7-8 games, I predict, and then when Henson is
forced behind center his production will die off. Expect a
similar situation with Amani Toomer in New York--with Warner running
the offense Toomer will post his usual numbers, but when Manning is
eventually given the job his stats will drop off. It is easy to
see how GM Joe Wyly's WR situation could start off wonderful and end in
complete misery--this is why his group has been given such a low
ranking.
Ranked #12 -- Chad Johnson / Larry Fitzgerald: One is an established
receiver with a young quarterback who should have a good season, the
other is a rookie with a garbage quarterback on a team without a
running threat, and missing their established receiver. Chad
Johnson's numbers will suffer slightly with Carson Palmer at QB, but
should still see good production. I am obviously not sold on the
tremendously talented Larry Fitzgerald as a #2, however, because McCown
is going to struggle mightily--especially with no run support.
Fitzgerald is much more suited to be a #3 fantasy wideout this year,
and because GM Joe Sr. has no other options at the position, he is
stuck with the #12 WR ranking. Boo hoo.
|
|
Starting TE |
Backups |
Rank |
|
'tude |
Gonzalez |
|
1 |
|
Reservoir |
Winslow Jr. |
|
2 |
|
SSFFPA |
Heap |
|
3 |
|
|
Crumpler |
|
4 |
|
Capitol |
Shockey |
|
5 |
|
IHOP |
Williams | |
6 |
|
MHTM |
Witten / Gates |
|
7 |
|
Hostile |
McMichael |
|
8 |
|
Chico |
Graham |
|
9 |
|
JVE |
Franks / Smith |
|
10 |
|
Kooter |
Pollard |
|
11 |
|
DarkSide |
Kinney |
|
12 |
We all know what the
deal is
here. Gonzalez is in a class of his own,
and GM Vince thought he was worth a second round draft pick. He
was probably right. Attitude Adjustment wins the TE
lottery. Following Vince with the #2 ranking is GM Joe Wyly
having
drafted Kellen Winslow, Jr. Sure to be QB Jeff Garcia's favorite
target amongst a group of average, albeit speedy receivers, Winslow has
the potential to accumulate numbers rivaling Gonzalez production.
After that at #3 we have Todd Heap on SSFFPA, and at #4, to GM Angelo,
Alge Crumpler--who should benefit from Vick's return and see his TD
production improve playing the safety valve role in Atlanta. At
#5 we have the always-injured Jeremy Shockey to Capitol Punishment, who
will probably still put up his large yardage numbers and lack of TDs,
and then Boo Williams to IHOP who may be the most underrated TE in the
draft, capable of great numbers and perhaps even third highest in point
total amongst his kind. Rounding out the TE class we have Jason
Witten and Antonio Gates to GM Geoff who has a controversy on his hands
at the position, and then Randy McMichael to Hostile Takeover who may
benefit from a stale offense in Miami and the need to look at other
options than Chambers due to double-teams. After that, it's kind
of a wash as far as TEs go, with the remaining four guys being pretty
average and simply ranked according to statistical trend analysis.
|
|
Starting Defense |
Backups |
Rank |
|
Capitol |
New England |
|
1 |
|
DarkSide |
Baltimore |
|
2 |
|
Hostile |
Carolina / Denver |
|
3 |
|
|
Philly |
|
4 |
|
IHOP |
Tampa
Bay |
|
5 |
|
T&A |
Dallas |
|
6 |
|
'tude |
Miami |
|
7 |
|
Kooter |
St. Louis / Oakland |
|
8 |
|
Chico |
Pittsburgh |
|
9 |
|
JVE |
KC |
|
10 |
|
SSFFPA |
Minnesota |
|
11 |
|
Reservoir |
Washington |
|
12 |
|
|
QB |
RB (x2) |
WR (x2) |
TE |
DEF |
Avg. |
Rank |
Drafted |
+/- |
Result |
|
IHOP |
2 |
6 |
8 |
6 |
5 |
5.9 |
3 |
10 |
+7 |
excellent |
|
SSFFPA |
4 |
12 |
3 |
3 |
11 |
6.9 |
8 |
12 |
+5 |
excellent |
|
MTHM |
9 |
1 |
5 |
7 |
4 |
4.6 |
1 |
4 |
+3 |
great |
|
'tude |
5 |
7 |
9 |
1 |
7 |
6.4 |
7 |
8 |
+2 |
great |
|
Reservoir |
3 |
2 |
11 |
2 |
12 |
6.1 |
6 |
6 |
E |
good |
|
Chico |
7 |
4 |
1 |
9 |
9 |
5.0 |
2 |
2 |
E |
good |
|
DarkSide |
11 |
8 |
10 |
12 |
2 |
8.7 |
12 |
11 |
-1 |
average |
|
Capitol |
12 |
10 |
7 |
5 |
1 |
7.4 |
10 |
9 |
-1 |
average |
|
T&A |
6 |
11 |
2 |
4 |
6 |
6.0 |
4 |
3 |
-1 |
average |
|
Hostile |
8 |
3 |
12 |
8 |
3 |
7.0 |
9 |
5 |
-3 |
poor |
|
Kooter |
1 |
5 |
6 |
11 |
8 |
6.0 |
4 |
1 |
-3 |
poor |
|
JVE |
10 |
9 |
4 |
10 |
10 |
8.0 |
11 |
7 |
-5 |
horrible |
As far as predicted
money-winners go, we
have two top-4 draftees in Geoff and Jason slated to finish in the 1
and 2 positions, with IHOP almost an entire point away (.9) coming up
in third. There are your division winners, kids. Rich for
DI, Jason
for DII, and Geoff for DIII. Losing their divisions are Joe in
DI, JV in DII, and Reservior Dogs in DIII. How about that
plummet, kids? Pat slides down from DI to DIII in the blink of an
eye. The wild card goes to Kooter... he will trade McNair away to
improve his squad well enough to make playoffs.